We are entering an era where climate risk is the defining variable in agriculture and resilient food systems. Extreme weather events are disrupting primary production and eroding agri-SME profitability, playing havoc in rural economies, driving employment losses and destabilising global supply chains. Smallholder farmers who produce 30-35% of the global food supply, contribute the least to climate change, and bear the brunt with shocks often wiping out harvests and cutting incomes.

Beyond the farmers, climate shocks raise the cost of risk in ways that strain the core economics of agricultural business models. For many value chain actors sourcing from farmers or agricultural service providers, the impact of climate shocks implies a full recalibration of whether the business model works at all under the new climate reality. Financial systems are also exposed: banks may risk rising non-performing loans in agricultural portfolios, insurers may withdraw from high-risk zones, and investors remain hesitant to deploy capital at scale due to perceived risks.

Building resilience to climate shocks starts with meeting the adaptation needs of smallholder producers and rural agri enterprises. These include access to new technologies including inputs or mechanisation that can reduce yield losses, logistics solutions that can increase access to markets and processing and storage solutions that can build resilience by allowing farmers and agri-SMEs to capture more value and lowering post-harvest losses. The transition to greater climate adaptation measures further supports climate and income resilience by enhancing soil health, improving water retention and reducing fertiliser use.

But the adoption of these technologies and practices requires significant upfront investment that most farmers and agri-SMEs can’t afford and that most financial services providers aren’t willing to finance. Studies by CPI suggest weather variability alone may drive a 20-30% increase in smallholder short-term working capital needs, due to costs for e.g., drought-tolerant seeds, and pest-resistant inputs. Mechanisation and infrastructure (e.g., small-scale irrigation, water harvesting) may collectively add another 25–35% to baseline capital expenditure. This is without counting defensive adaptive strategies and emergency support (e.g., cash transfers or insurance payouts) to manage shocks post-occurrence. As a result, and despite the urgency, only 7.2% of climate finance reaches agrifood systems, and a mere 1.7% reaches small-scale producers, leading to an estimated smallholder climate adaptation finance gap of USD 75–150 billion.

Where are we today? Adaptation finance at a crossroads

The good news is while the gap is still huge, the narrative is shifting. Resilience is increasingly seen as good business, not just a moral imperative. There’s growing investor interest in climate adaptation investments, with recognition that adaptation is no longer just about “doing good” and supporting those that are most vulnerable, but also about avoiding losses and building the foundations for resilient farmers, agri-businesses, and global supply chains. For buyers and food companies in particular, resilient supply chains are proving to be competitive. Investing upstream to build resilience is becoming a procurement strategy, not just corporate social responsibility. Nestle for instance has committed to sourcing 50% of key ingredients (including cocoa and coffee) from farmers using regenerative practices by 2030 (20% by 2025).

“At Nestlé, we are firmly on track with our goals on regenerative agriculture. At the end of 2024, just over 21% of our key ingredients came from farmers adopting regenerative practices and we continue to roll out projects with farming communities around the world. For us, this is about supporting these communities to build resilience both for them and for our supply chain, securing the sustainability of food systems for the future.” – Owen Bethell, Environmental Lead, Global Public Affairs, Nestlé.

Solutions also exist. From climate-smart irrigation to adaptive insurance, soil health platforms, nature-based asset finance to blended funds backing local financial intermediaries. But these efforts remain fragmented and undercapitalised. According to AgBase investment in climate-smart ag ventures is concentrated in a handful of solutions (10 solutions received 70% of total funding to climate-smart ag solutions from 2014-2024) and less than 80% of AgTech solutions in sub-Saharan Africa are unable to raise a second deal, stalling between pilot and scale-up stage despite having climate relevance and early traction.

Finally, capital is also increasingly available. Though it’s not deployed in the right form, at the right time, or priced for the realities on the ground. There continues to be a mismatch between investor impact and financial return timelines and what is realistic in terms of outcomes – climate-smart investments often take years to pay off which makes it hard to engage for investors and donors with shorter-term horizons. For instance, the much-needed technical assistance for the climate transition usually has a time horizon of four years or less – far too short to meet associated targets. Systemic risk perceptions are even higher than real risk, particularly when risk correlates across borrowers and regions. And we continue to miss tailored financial products to meet climate adaptation needs.

Seizing the opportunity: Five key lessons from London Climate Action Week

So if the case for building resilience is so clear and the tools for capital are there, how can we rewire the systems so that adaptation finance delivers to both smallholder farmers, agri-SMEs and capital providers? On June 24 2025, IDH Farmfit Fund, Acumen and ISF Advisors brought over 55 investors and practitioners to discuss investment strategies to fill the climate finance gap. Five key lessons emerged.

1. Adopt a systemic lens, grounding investment strategies in market realities

Investments must move beyond isolated solutions to consider the full agri-food ecosystem and the realities of local contexts. System-level thinking is essential to address the structural and context-specific vulnerabilities that prevent finance from flowing to agricultural markets like fragmented value chains, ‘missing middle’ financing, and inadequate infrastructure. Investment strategies that work in more mature agricultural markets that are well into the transition to market-based finance (e.g., Zambia Cotton or Brazil Soybeans) will likely not be replicable in less developed and higher risk agricultural markets, such as the more smallholder-intensive maize markets in sub-Saharan Africa. Holistic and adaptive approaches tailored to local system maturity, actor capacity, and incentive structures are essential.

For example, Aldea Familia, an IDH Farmfit Fund investee, applies a systemic, farmer-centric approach by integrating digital tools, tailored inputs, processing infrastructure, and financial services across its different business entities, creating a holistic model that addresses multiple barriers faced by farmers to increase their income and build resilience. The IDH Farmfit Fund supported this model with two reinforcing investments: first in Aldea’s coffee mill to strengthen value addition, and later in its MFI to scale access to agroforestry finance, including climate-smart solutions like Rabobank’s Acorn carbon program. Together, these investments demonstrate how supporting multiple, interconnected levers within a single ecosystem can drive more resilient, scalable impact. More information here.

In Colombia, IDH is developing a platform that will provide innovative financing to help coffee farmers transition to climate-resilient practices. This will be supported by a financing facility for technical assistance, working capital and long-term investments, conceived and structured with a systemic investing approach to maximise impact. This effort requires collaboration across the value chain, including farmers, agri-SMEs, coffee traders and brands, fintechs and agritechs, as well as the government, and is grounded in a shared vision of what it takes to transition to climate-resilient practices, what levers can be pulled and who can best fill different capital needs.

2. Leverage strategic partnerships

No single actor will be able to tackle the climate adaptation challenge alone. Blended finance works best when anchored in strongly trusted and aligned partnerships between capital providers, enterprises, and enablers with aligned objectives. Promising models like ARAF, FASA or Ireme Invest demonstrate that partnerships between concessional investors, enterprises, and enabling actors that are addressing the underlying vulnerabilities of agricultural markets are critical for anchoring long-term strategies and meeting the return and impact requirements of investors.

For instance, Acumen via ARAF, has been successful in setting up an innovative blended finance model that combines concessional first-loss capital with commercially oriented senior equity, helping to de-risk investments in early-stage agribusinesses and crowd in private capital. The fund’s structure includes $23 million in catalytic first-loss equity from the Green Climate Fund (GCF), paired with $25 million in senior equity and $3 million in grant capital for a $6 million Technical Assistance Facility (TAF). This structure is designed not only to attract more risk-averse investors by protecting their downside but also to strengthen the climate resilience and financial viability of its investees through tailored technical support. The fund closed with oversubscription in 2021, building on Acumen’s 10+ years of previous agriculture investing. To date, the fund has invested in 14 agribusinesses in Ghana, Nigeria, Kenya, Tanzania, and Uganda impacting over 1.2 million farmers.

3. Invest in measurement and data

What gets measured gets financed. Unlike mitigation, where there is a clear North Star, the reduction or removal of greenhouse gases, climate adaptation does not have one single universal metric. Yet standardised adaptation metrics, like “perceived adaptation” and “resilience to actual shocks”, are now emerging to track both financial and climate outcomes. Better data also combats investor biases and can help close the risk perception gap.

Acumen and ARAF, for instance, partnered with 60Decibels to embed resilience measurement across its investment portfolio. To date the tool has been applied for over five years on over 5,000 farmers, post investment, to better understand how our investments are supporting farmers to become more (or less) resilient, and to help inform our investment decision making. Furthermore, within Trellis, their philanthropic backed early stage Ag fund, Acumen has dedicated resources to measuring impact at the farmer level prior to every investment, to ensure that the farmer’s voice is included in the investment decision making.

The resilience tool is based on measuring resilience across three key pillars: Ability to adapt, ability to access enablers, and ability to absorb a shock. Below is a table that provides more detail on the specific indicators being considered:

Figure 1: Acumen ARAF Resilience Measuring Tool

Similarly, IDH Farmfit Fund partners with IDH Insights Hub, an online platform that provides data, tools, and learnings on smallholder farmer inclusive business models. Reliable data can provide great insight in the actual financing needs and how meeting those needs can increase farmer resilience. For example, in the case of an Ugandan coffee company, IDH Insights Hub estimated farmers need an average of three years to implement a regenerative agriculture system and seven to eight years to fully transform to regenerative agriculture. While the cashflow from diverse crops (excluding coffee) is expected to be positive from year-2, the total farm investment needs peaks in year-3, hence providing finance to farmers during the initial three years can substantially ease the burden on their cashflows. This type of data allows for tailored investment structures and timelines to the financial needs of farmers and the providers serving them.

4. Tap market-based instruments and anchor value chain actors, where there are incentives

In markets where there is a commercial incentive to secure supply, off-takers, and aggregators hold the key to scaling adaptation solutions and building resilience in global supply chains in a financially sustainable way. Research by ISF Advisors shows that off-takers can provide finance at up to three times lower cost than alternative channels by leveraging existing sourcing infrastructure and absorbing lending costs to strengthen procurement – creating returns that go well beyond the loan itself and that could finance smallholder farmer investments in climate adaptation solutions.

Compared to traditional finance service providers, offtakers have significantly lower operational costs. They leverage existing sourcing infrastructure – trucks, staff, relationships – to deliver finance at marginal cost. The real difference though, is how offtakers think about benefits. Offtakers don’t price lending to cover costs. They do it because it enables their core business.

For offtakers sourcing from smallholder farmers, lending drives more reliable volumes, higher-quality produce, and sourcing economies of scale. In a good season with no shock, sourcing benefits – particularly the uplift in sourcing volumes resulting from uplift in farmer yields and / or loyalty through the use of inputs – are able to outweigh the cost and risk of lending for most providers. In a bad season, however, when a climate or market shocks hits, the cost of risk spikes and can erase most or all the associated sourcing benefits.

The key question is: do the profits of the good seasons outweigh the losses of bad seasons?

ISF research suggests that for most providers the overall business case of lending to smallholder farmers remains positive when the overtime sourcing benefits are taken into account.

Figure 2: Four-year total lending margins for selected offtakers financings smallholder farmers (% of balance)

5. Mobilise government leadership

In many agricultural markets, especially those dominated by subsistence farming and challenging underlying commodity market conditions, commercial capital will struggle to meet investment return thresholds. And even those that are attractive, catalytic public investment and policy action remain essential to crowd in private capital. Governments play a key role in shaping a fit-for-purpose agri finance market.

In the early stages of agri-finance market development, country governments typically play a lead role in financing the agricultural sector through subsidy programs, state banks, and direct provision of retail credit. However, state-driven credit is often allocated based on political influence with predictable results: uneven distribution and low repayment rates. Even when done well, governments can only extend so much agri-finance before running into natural fiscal limits. As a result, as agricultural and financial markets mature, countries naturally transition to more market-based financing approaches. To enable the transition to market-led systems, governments must become regulators and market catalysts for private sector financial service providers.

Governments can strengthen their enabling role by establishing a distinct, pluralistic, and market-based agri-finance agenda, investing in the right regulatory and infrastructure “building blocks,” and using targeted interventions to unlock private capital while ensuring markets serve national climate and development priorities. ISF latest research on the role of government in supporting ag finance markets a framework for how macro-level foundations and meso-level building blocks enable market development before exploring the effectiveness of different market-catalyzing approaches, typically applied at the micro level. For example in Uganda, tax breaks to solar powered agricultural technologies have been key for the sustainability of business models such as SunCulture, allowing them to expand financing to more smallholders.

Figure 3: Agri-finance maturity scorecard

Where do we go from here

The case is clear. The tools are emerging. The capital exists. The challenge is now execution and coordination.

As we look toward African Food Systems Forum, NY Climate Week, Building Bridges, COP30, and other global events, this conversation must remain front and center. We invite funders, enterprises, and policy makers to connect with us and join us in transforming adaptation finance into a mainstream investment priority.

For further learning opportunities please check out:
– Learnings from IDH Farmfit Fund’s five-year journey
– Case studies from Acumen’s Roots of Resilience report spotlighting two social enterprises building smallholder farmer resilience
– ISF’s upcoming Agri-Finance State of the Sector report & Value Chain Finance Series

Related Research

ISF Webinar: Beyond the Frontier – Decoding Viability in Smallholder Finance

Watch the full webinar recording where ISF Advisors and industry leaders unpack insights from Beyond the Frontier: Decoding Viability in Smallholder Finance, exploring the practical shifts needed to build sustainable and scalable smallholder finance models.

Read More →
ISF Advisors Launches Global Report on $200B+ Smallholder Finance Gap Amid Rising Climate Pressures

PRESS RELEASE: ISF Advisors has launched the 2025 Rural and Agricultural Finance State of the Sector Report, Beyond the Frontier: Decoding Viability in Smallholder Finance — a landmark global study charting how the world can close the USD 200 billion smallholder finance gap. The report reveals pathways to unlock sustainable lending for smallholder farmers who produce nearly 30 percent of the world’s food.

Read More →
Beyond the Frontier: Decoding Viability in Smallholder Finance

ISF Advisors has launched the 2025 Rural and Agricultural Finance State of the Sector Report: Beyond the Frontier: Decoding Viability in Smallholder Finance. The report explores how to shift the “viability frontier” to unlock new pathways for smallholder finance. It builds on over a decade of ISF research and global collaboration, offering practical strategies to help funders, investors, and providers expand access to finance for millions of smallholder farmers.

Read More →

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Business-to-business (B2B) agricultural technology (agtechs) are on the rise throughout the Global South, creating entirely new possibilities for clients working with smallholder farmers – from banks, to offtakers, to microfinance institutions (MFIs) and cooperatives. However, their growth trajectories have varied drastically, with some players (such as CropIn) achieving significant scale and others (such as Gro Intelligence) folding. In this blog, we examine the nuances behind these B2B solutions and share our perspective on the market trajectory over the coming years.

The Emerging Landscape of B2B AgTechs

Stakeholders working with smallholder farmers are increasingly searching for innovative ways to transform or enhance their operations, comply with new regulations and sustainability commitments, or help farmers adapt to changing climates. In parallel, there has been a rapid influx in the number and types of digital solutions in smallholder farmer markets over the past decade. While there is substantial literature around business-to-consumer (B2C) solutions that directly engage with smallholder farmers to provide services such as advisory, inputs, or financing, literature has been limited on the growing subset of B2B solutions.

Instead of interacting directly with smallholder farmers, these B2B offerings play an enabling role in these environments, targeting a broad range of stakeholders that work with smallholders with distinct value propositions:

  • Financial service providers, to support improved risk monitoring and decision making when lending to smallholder farmers
  • Agribusinesses, to improve smallholder relationship management and enhance supply chain operations
  • Agri-SMEs, to accelerate decision making and reduce transaction costs

There’s no doubt that working in smallholder farmer landscapes can be difficult. And for many of these sector stakeholders, building and maintaining tailored solutions for smallholder farmer markets in-house is both cost-prohibitive and not aligned with their core competencies. As such, the rise of these third-party B2B solution providers creates novel service and business model possibilities that should be seen for what they are: an entirely new service landscape.

Landscape of B2B Players in Smallholder Farmer Markets

The boom of B2B solution providers for smallholder markets over the past decade provides a unique opportunity for the aforementioned diverse set of players to engage these digital solutions to transform their operations. While each individual agtech company has a unique business model, our research has demonstrated that models in smallholder markets tend to center around 4 key solution categories:

1. Supply Chain Management

This subset of solutions works with agribusinesses to digitally optimize their supply chain operations. Some solutions focus upstream to onboard and digitize farmers and SMEs, others offer post-farm logistics services, and many players, such as Farmerline, are evolving to offer end-to-end supply chain management and farm-to-fork traceability.

This is arguably one of the largest and most successful subset of B2B solutions, with many players establishing product market fit and consistently updating and expanding product offerings to meet market needs. In the coming years, increasing demand for traceability services from consumers and governments alike will likely lead to continued growth of this solution provider category.

2. Financial Access Enablers

These agtechs support the provision of financial services to smallholder populations. Many of these agtechs are digitally-enabled credit and insurance providers that offer products specific to the needs of smallholder farmers. For instance, Pula offers smallholder farmer insurance products to mitigate risks associated with external shocks (e.g. weather, pest and disease outbreaks). 

Another subset of this category is Financial Analytics players. These agtechs often collect or leverage alternative data sources around the financial habits of farmers to lower the cost to serve and cost of risk for these hard-to-reach populations and ultimately support financial service providers in lending decisions.

3. Information and Advisory Services

This subset of models engages with agribusinesses or other agtechs to deliver key advisory information, such as weather or market price, to their farmer networks. More advanced models also leverage precision agriculture to curate advisory content based on farm conditions.

Advisory services aren’t only needed at the smallholder farmer level. Select B2B players in this subset target financial service providers and agribusiness to support agroclimatic risk intelligence. These players often utilize remote sensing and machine learning to remotely monitor fields or establish agroclimatic risk scores around varied metrics, including soil health, crop health, and predicted rainfall. Services such as SatSure are leading the way in this space, offering remote crop loan portfolio monitoring and farm risk reports.

4. Market Linkage Services

Additionally, digital platform-based models enable various stakeholders to access wider markets where they can buy and sell goods to and from smallholder farmers, access services from other agripreneurs, and/or share information. A variety of B2C and B2B platform models exist, as discussed in our recent blog, An Updated View of Digital Marketplace Platforms. However, many of the models that began as asset-lite pure-play marketplaces have had to pivot to make unit economics work. One way successful models are doing so is by shifting from B2C to B2B models. Through this transition, they naturally limit links with smallholder farmers and pivot their focus to fast-moving consumer goods and retail shops, which tends to result in higher profit margins.

A Variety of B2B Models Exist in Smallholder Farmer Markets

While this mapping of providers is based on core offerings in today’s market, there is certainly a fluidity of models. Many solution providers are rapidly iterating or adjusting their offerings to find product market fit and diversify revenue streams. This can be seen in the case of CropIn, which began as a farmer-facing platform in 2010 then quickly pivoted to offering B2B supply chain management solutions for agribusinesses in 2013. Since then CropIn has substantially expanded its suite of services and targets a variety of players, including financial service providers, governments, insurance providers, and others.

ISF Perspective on the Market Trajectory

While players in each of these categories are successfully leveraging digitization to fill market gaps, they remain at varying stages of the innovation cycle. Our extensive research on this new service landscape showcased a few trends:

  • Solutions that target agribusinesses are the frontrunners. This is particularly true for supply chain management solutions – such as CropIn and SatSure – whose business models are consistently evolving to meet market demands. Many of these solutions are also adding additional offerings that target other stakeholders, such as financial service providers, as noted in the example of CropIn.
  • Solutions that target financial service providers are on the rise, but have yet to achieve product market fit. This is the case for many agroclimatic risk solutions which show great potential, but suffer from lack of demand on the financial service provider side. These solutions provide very relevant offerings that will be increasingly important with climate change, however by-the-book financial service providers often appear hesitant to engage with these innovative players who use novel approaches for risk decisioning. The repercussions of this are beginning to show with major layoffs at many companies, such as Gro Intelligence.
  • Despite this varied supply and demand, the B2B services market is the right approach in smallholder farmer markets. While we have seen a few large agribusiness players (e.g. Olam) develop in-house supply chain management solutions, this is not feasible or sustainable for most businesses working with smallholder farmers. Therefore, Software as a Service (SaaS) providers help to democratize the potential for these offerings, especially for local and regional agribusinesses and agri-SMEs who do not have the resources nor capital to develop solutions on their own. Furthermore, most financial service providers lack the in-house expertise and capabilities to build and effectively and maintain these solutions.

Given these dynamics, we strongly believe that there is a genuine opportunity for these B2B solution providers to flourish in the long run. However, many providers will face an uphill battle in the short term. In the coming years we anticipate that seasoned players will further evolve their core offerings to meet market demands, young players will continue to iterate their offerings in attempts to achieve product market fit, and net new solution categories will emerge to capitalize on newer market opportunities, such as carbon credits.

This blog was authored by Sarah Devermann, Matt Shakhovskoy, and Clara Colina.

Get in Touch

If this has sparked interest or you would like to discuss ISF’s market perspective further, please reach out to:

 

  • Matt Shakhovskoy – ISF Director (matt.shakhovskoy@isfadvisors.org)
  • Clara Colina – ISF Director (clara.colina@isfadvisors.org)

Related Research

How Capital Enhances Resilience: Five Lessons Learned

Capital is key to resilience. IDH Farmfit Fund, Acumen, and ISF Advisors share five lessons on scaling climate adaptation finance for smallholder farmers — and building stronger, more resilient food systems.

Read More →
Examining the Fragility of the AgTech Ecosystem Behind the Headline Numbers

A summary of ISF’s comparative analysis between the agtech ecosystem and other ecosystems serving low and middle-income populations, including key drivers of innovation ecosystems, the relative maturity of different countries, and best and worst-case scenarios for the future of agtech ecosystems in the Global South.

Read More →
An Updated View of Digital Marketplace Platforms

An update to our digital platforms research that reevaluates the sector to understand why agri-marketplace platforms have struggled to reach their potential. It outlines new thinking around how we segment agricultural marketplace platforms, key challenges & emerging successes, and future potential for embedded finance within these models.

Read More →

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

There is no doubt that the agricultural technology (agtech) ecosystem is rapidly maturing. This is demonstrated by both the number of solutions in the market and the influx of funding that has been invested. But while headline numbers signify a maturing ecosystem, the reality is that many actors, especially in the Global South, struggle to achieve product-market fit and scale. Recent setbacks of once-promising models like Gro Intelligence, Twiga, and Copia underscore these complexities.

To unpack this, ISF Advisors facilitated a comparative analysis between the agtech ecosystem and other ecosystems serving low and middle-income populations. This exploration shed light on the key drivers of innovation ecosystems, the relative maturity of different countries, and an analysis of best and worst-case scenarios for the future of agtech ecosystems in the Global South.

The Trajectory of Innovation Ecosystems

Innovation ecosystems – defined as the network of actors, relationships, and resources that play a role in taking an idea to transformative impact at scale – flourish under the following conditions:

  • Proven, scalable business models that have gained traction and commercial viability
  • The presence of later-stage deals, exits, and even unicorns
  • Large and diverse investment flows from both foreign and local investors
  • Local IP and patents
  • Equitable and inclusive governance and participation

To get to this state, ecosystems servicing low and middle-income customers tend to follow a common trajectory. This was seen with microfinance in the 1960s, PAYGO solar providers in the early 2000s, and most recently agtechs and financial technology (fintechs) in the past decade (see detailed examples in the attached slide deck).

As documented in the graphic below, ecosystems start in the irruption phase when an early group of solutions with common hypotheses enter the market. At this stage, adoption and growth tend to be slow and funding is constrained, leading many founders to bootstrap or rely on grant funding. Eventually, the solutions gain traction and massive growth begins – often defined as a “bubble” – with new innovators and ecosystem actors entering the market. During this phase, actors typically operate in siloes, and enabling environment actors are playing catch up.

Typical Evolution of Innovation Ecosystems

Then comes a turning point, often in the form of a major success story such as an exit or acquisition (e.g. Stripe acquiring Nigeria’s PayStack), that helps prove the potential of solution growth and leads ecosystems into the synergy phase. In these relatively mature ecosystems, actors begin working together to address barriers, commercial funding becomes dominant, and there is supportive infrastructure and talent to support solutions. In the final stage, the adoption of solutions is widespread. Due to saturated markets, new businesses start to spin off into adjacent sectors, as was seen with early fintech innovators (e.g. Tala, Branch) launching off the backs of microfinance institutions (MFIs).

The State of the AgTech Ecosystem

By examining the burgeoning agtech ecosystem against these common ecosystem trajectories, we see that the strength of the innovation ecosystem varies widely across regions and even markets within each region.

In mapping the number of agtech solutions across the strength of ecosystem maturity, it becomes clear that:

  • Global North agtech ecosystems are small but mighty. Despite the relatively small agriculture value-add in markets such as Israel, Germany, and France, they are frontrunners for innovation.
  • Brazil and India are Global South frontrunners. Excluding China, these two markets are far ahead of their regional counterparts in terms of ecosystem strength. We examine potential reasons for this in the next section.
  • All sub-Saharan African agtech ecosystems remain at a relatively early stage of ecosystem development. While frontrunners Kenya and Nigeria are lauded for their startup ecosystems on the continent, even these sub-Saharan African ecosystems remain relatively immature when compared to other regions.

 

Maturity of AgTech Innovation Ecosystems Across Global South & Global North

Examining the Front Runners

As noted above, Brazil and India are far outpacing their Global South peers. Several similarities between these countries have helped drive this growth, including:

  • Very large domestic markets, given the strong reliance on agriculture and sheer population size
  • Favorable local startup ecosystems, with a track record of innovation and technology-based companies
  • Available funding, due to burgeoning start-up scenes and dedicated commercial investors in the sector (e.g. Omnivore, SP Ventures)
  • Favorable government programs and policies for the start-up sector and/or agriculture sector, including the existence of digital public infrastructure 

The success of the agtech ecosystem in both countries is dependent on an array of actors, including startups, funders, and regulators. The maturity in these markets can be largely attributed to the favorable conditions across these user groups.

AgTech Ecosystem Trajectories of Global South Frontrunners: India & Brazil

Where Does the AgTech Ecosystem Go From Here?

Where the agtech ecosystem goes from here is dependent on a variety of factors. While there are promising signs of growth and innovation globally, the journey is fraught with challenges in achieving widespread scalability and product-market fit, especially in regions like sub-Saharan Africa. The successes of frontrunners such as Brazil, India, and many Global North markets highlight the potential for impactful change driven by robust startup ecosystems, available funding, and supportive regulatory frameworks.

In the best-case scenario, it could flourish as a globally integrated ecosystem driven by regional anchors (e.g. India, Brazil, Kenya, Singapore), with accessible commercial capital and supportive enabling environments. However, there’s also the potential for it to become persistently divided, with models in less mature markets stagnating and succumbing to funding cliffs.

To achieve the best-case scenario outcome, collaboration between stakeholders is key. This includes donors continuing to fund key research, data providers increasing transparency into sector funding flows, regulators fostering progressive policies, funders taking a bet on the sector, and innovators continuing to develop commercially viable models. By fostering collaboration and learning from the successes and setbacks of similar ecosystems, we can drive towards a globally integrated agtech ecosystem.

This blog was authored by Sarah Devermann, Matt Shakovskoy, and Clara Colina.

Get in Touch

If this has sparked interest or you would like to discuss ISF’s market perspective further, please reach out to:

 

  • Matt Shakhovskoy – ISF Director (matt.shakhovskoy@isfadvisors.org)
  • Clara Colina – ISF Director (clara.colina@isfadvisors.org)

Slides for Further Reading

Related Research

AgTech Investment in Emerging Markets 2025

AgTech investment across emerging markets is no longer one story. Drawing on $4.39 billion in funding across 17 markets, this State of the Sector report examines what’s driving increasingly divergent investment trajectories and introduces the Investable Frontier, a framework for understanding where different types of capital and business models are best suited.

Read More →
Agricultural Insurance Deep Dive: Strengthening linkages between agri-finance and agri-insurance

Developed with UNDP’s Insurance and Risk Finance Facility, the Agricultural Insurance Deep Dive examines how better integration between agri-insurance and agri-finance can reduce risk, unlock investment, and strengthen resilience across agricultural value chains.

Read More →
Opportunities for Scaling Up Value Chain Finance

Explore what it takes to scale Value Chain Finance (VCF) across diverse markets. This article introduces a three-level framework for intervention — from capital to coordination and policy — and highlights how local and regional offtakers can be empowered to deliver embedded finance at scale.

Read More →

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

In our 2021 Agricultural Platforms in a Digital Era report, ISF presented a definition of “Platforms” defined by two distinguishing factors:

1) They are built upon network effects, enabling multiple users on both sides of an exchange to interact.

2) Unlike traditional “pipeline businesses” they do not produce goods or services, but rather link users together to access goods and services.

In that report and subsequent updates, we evaluated the potential role that marketplace platform models connecting users with products or integrated products and services could play in helping smallholder farmers (SHFs) and agricultural small- and medium-sized enterprises (agri-SMEs) overcome many of the market barriers inherent in the sector. The promise of agri-marketplace platforms is clear:

  1. Many digital agri-marketplaces have characteristics that create strong potential for platforms to help markets clear.
  2. Agri-marketplaces are theoretically well-positioned as a channel to scale up financing to SHFs and agricultural micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs).

However, platform models have struggled to realize this potential. This update offers a reevaluation of the sector to understand why this is the case. It outlines new thinking around how we segment agricultural marketplace platforms, evaluates the key challenges and emerging success stories in the space, and discusses the current state and future potential for embedded finance (i.e., integrated financial services or products) within these models.

Broader Market Evolution

Our evaluation of how digital marketplaces have proliferated in developing countries reveals clear differences between services-based marketplaces, general e-commerce marketplaces that cover rural areas, and agriculture-specific marketplaces:

  • Services-based marketplaces built around transport services have rapidly multiplied and matured into diversified businesses that cover delivery, mobility, entertainment, and financial services (e.g. Bolt in Africa, Grab and GoJek in Asia).
  • Fast-moving consumer goods-anchored general product marketplaces have similarly grown into major companies including Pinduoduo, Rural Taobao (Alibaba’s rural brand), Flipkart, and Shopee, with a range of embedded vendor finance, buy-now-pay later, and insurance offerings.
  • Agricultural marketplaces as a niche vertical have struggled to establish pure-play digital platforms (i.e., focused solely on facilitating a digital exchange between suppliers and consumers of goods/services), with almost every business pivoting to either focus on a niche service or deeply embedding themselves in value chains as active facilitators.

Making the unit economics work for pure-play, digital infrastructure-based platforms in agricultural marketplaces is challenging for many reasons: the seasonality of trade, low-transaction values around smallholder production systems, the fragmented and highly localized nature of many supply chains, the low digital literacy/digital access of many smallholder farmers, and the low level of maturity of many enabling sectors including transport, logistics, storage/cold chain, and payments.

Whilst this is true across all developing countries, it should be noted that the enabling environment in China and India is much more advanced (e.g., high levels of rural internet penetration, government support for market-based solutions connecting farmers with value chain actors and service providers, significant enabling digital public infrastructure). We see this reflected in both investment trends, the number of models, and the results of those models. In Africa, Kenya, Nigeria, and South Africa also clearly stand out as leaders, even as those markets lag the current progress in India.

Emerging Agriculture-specific Marketplace Business Models

Our 2021 report revealed a wide range of marketplace platform models operating in the agricultural sector. Broadly, we divided them into three models:

  1. Product marketplace: connects smallholder farmers to physical markets both to and from the farm, including farm inputs suppliers and various kinds of off-takers (processors, trader, retailers, consumers).
  2. Integrated product and services marketplace: facilitates access to a holistic, bundled offer to farmers. Similar to a product marketplace, but offering broader range of services to farmers.
  3. Services marketplace: shared economy platform that links farmers to equipment and/or other service providers.

Whilst many companies started with expectations of running digital e-commerce marketplaces in agriculture, we are seeing all of them pivot into a range of different business model orientations (many of which still integrate a marketplace function) that involve much deeper integration into agricultural markets. Many of these models are still attempting to find their niche and scale, but to make some sense of the market we’ve segmented models within the broader 3 buckets primarily based on emerging positioning within the value chain:

Considering this landscape of nine sub-segments, it has become clear that:

  • The only product marketplace models that are succeeding are those with limited links to smallholder farmers:
    • Both the Food Delivery (business-to-consumer (B2C) companies connecting food retailers with end consumers) and Re-Stockists (business-to-business (B2B) distributor platforms typically selling a combination of produce and fast-moving consumer goods to retail shops) segments have experienced growth. However, the former offers no direct link to smallholder farmers while the latter has limited links on the fresh produce sourcing side.
    • We anticipate further consolidation in the Re-Stockist landscape due to the sector’s hyper-competitive dynamics, characterized by thin margins and operational intricacies such as multi-homing customers. The recent challenges faced by the once-successful Twiga underscore these pressures.
    • Other product marketplace models have all had to pivot to either B2B models or a broader set of services.
  • A range of integrated product and services marketplace models are working at scale with high levels of market infrastructure (e.g., input supply or sourcing networks/warehouses) and often direct participation in output markets (e.g., commodity trading). 
    • There are three foundational variations in these models with a range of other differences in how they configure distribution, product bundling and finance. However, all of these models now need to be considered as marketplace-hybrids as the marketplace element of the model is now only one (often small) part of how they claim margin.
  • A small set of farm services marketplaces exist in the form of tractor and other equipment (e.g., irrigation) rental companies that are proving capital-intensive to scale with limited embedded finance outside of some leasing finance for the tractor owners.

The Rise & Potential of Digitally Native Marketplace Hybrids

Moving forward, we expect a handful of business models within the Integrated Product & Services Marketplace segment to emerge from the dynamic landscape and achieve commercially viable scale. These Digitally Native Marketplace Hybrids are poised for success across various value chain positions:

  • Farm & Input Services focused on the input portion of the market and leveraging strong relationships with farmers and access to data (e.g., DeHaat, DigiFarm, Farmcrowdy).
  • Commodity Exchange+ models emphasizing the output portion of the value chain through a combination of trade facilitation, service provision, and cross-subsidized commodity trading (e.g., AFEX, Origo, Nile.ag).
  • Dual-focused Holistic Marketplaces utilizing their key position across the value chain on both the input and offtake side but with a narrower commodity focus (e.g., Samunnati, AgroMall, AgroStar, Ninjacart).

Success for these Digitally Native Marketplace Hybrid models will depend on the establishment of physical infrastructures parallel to their digital platforms, enabling traditional margin capture for these companies across supply chains, financial services, and trade operations. Given the deep market integration associated with these models, growth trajectories will be largely dictated by country-specific agricultural market conditions, including inherent margins, market fragmentation, and the maturity of last-mile distribution networks.

The Embedded Finance Opportunity & Current State

Lending by agricultural marketplaces continues to be relatively niche (less than 2% of total agricultural lending today). This is primarily due to the challenges associated with scaling embedded finance, but more importantly, it reflects the nascent nature and limited scale of these marketplaces in general.

Within these ”marketplace models” embedded finance can typically take four primary forms:

Each of these forms of finance has a different positioning and value in the underlying models in the market:

  • Input finance is the most directly related finance for SHFs and is virtually non-existent. In Africa, no partnerships with financial service providers (FSPs) are working, and direct lending is either being done sporadically using equity or in the form of value-chain-finance where offtake/trading value can make up for the cost/risk (e.g. AFEX). In India, even highly scaled and well-capitalized models that are firmly entrenched in providing integrated farm services, such as DeHaat, are having limited success.
  • Buy-now-pay-later (BNPL) is being used with some frequency in Re-Stockist models and in a very limited way with input-marketplaces for SHFs. However, this finance is heavily constrained by the capital requirements of the marketplace providers and involves very high short-term interest rates for customers and can often be predatory in nature.
  • Trade finance is a key part of many marketplace models working on the offtake side of the market and can be both profitable and scalable, but has limited real impacts on SHFs. Models like AFEX, Origo, Samanati, and Ninjacart are providing trade finance to a range of small to medium traders and processors to finance inventory facilitated through the platform. These finance arrangements typically involve relatively longer loan tenors than input loans or BNPL products (e.g., 3-6 months) at interest rates typically ~15-25%, and when well managed have a reasonable cost of risk.
  • Warehouse receipt finance is being used in some instances by marketplace related models, especially those heavily integrated into the post-production value chain areas such as Commodity Exchange +, but are inherently more dependent on a tightly regulated system or specialized partnership.

Lending is being done largely in service of trying to establish market share (primarily through higher conversion rates and / or transaction sizes) and doesn’t yet seem to be a stand-alone profit-generating activity. While there are wide variations across models, the lending economics can be relatively streamlined on the operating expenses and cost of risk side (particularly for those with embedded de-risking mechanisms e.g. access to markets) but high cost of funds (particularly of earlier stage models), small loan sizes (e.g., rarely exceeding $500) and short tenures (e.g. maximum 3 months and typically much lower), make the unit economics challenging.

Most marketplaces that are providing lending are doing so directly off their own balance sheet – this is consistent across lending products and even more prevalent for input finance and BNPL. Due to tight margins in the core businesses, most have to finance their lending activities directly with equity, increasing fundraising demands and compounding risk.

Off-balance sheet finance models are essentially non-existent in Africa and only present at limited scale in India. A majority of the FSPs continue to be reluctant to underwrite credit to smallholders and agribusiness through agricultural marketplaces due to the limited scale, the lack of portfolio performance track record, and the uncertainty around the value and accessibility of data. When FSPs do engage (e.g., as in certain Indian marketplaces), they often do so at high interest rates, and / or with inadequate financial products that do not meet the needs of the SHF and / or MSME transacting through the platform.

Forward Outlook

It is becoming increasingly clear that any embedded finance in agricultural platforms might start to resemble traditional value chain finance rather than “standard” digital e-commerce financing. The highly nascent stage of the market means it is still too early to see which models and financial products will ultimately benefit target populations, and to assess the extent to which they can be replicated. But the concept of “marketplace hybrids” offers a new perspective, blending traditional value chain models with digital innovations. These hybrids could leverage new approaches to distribution, product bundling, and data utilization, providing interesting alternatives to traditional value chain finance models.

Get in Touch

If this has sparked interest or you would like to discuss ISF’s market perspective further, please reach out to:

 

  • Matt Shakhovskoy – ISF Director (matt.shakhovskoy@isfadvisors.org)
  • Hayden Aldredge – ISF Manager (hayden.aldredge@isfadvisors.org)

Slides for Further Reading

Related Research

How Capital Enhances Resilience: Five Lessons Learned

Capital is key to resilience. IDH Farmfit Fund, Acumen, and ISF Advisors share five lessons on scaling climate adaptation finance for smallholder farmers — and building stronger, more resilient food systems.

Read More →
The Rise of a New Market: B2B Technologies for Smallholder Farmer Markets

A blog examining the nuances behind business-to-business (B2B) agricultural technology emerging throughout the Global South, and sharing ISF’s perspective on the market trajectory over the coming years.

Read More →
Examining the Fragility of the AgTech Ecosystem Behind the Headline Numbers

A summary of ISF’s comparative analysis between the agtech ecosystem and other ecosystems serving low and middle-income populations, including key drivers of innovation ecosystems, the relative maturity of different countries, and best and worst-case scenarios for the future of agtech ecosystems in the Global South.

Read More →

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Related Research

AgTech Investment in Emerging Markets 2025

AgTech investment across emerging markets is no longer one story. Drawing on $4.39 billion in funding across 17 markets, this State of the Sector report examines what’s driving increasingly divergent investment trajectories and introduces the Investable Frontier, a framework for understanding where different types of capital and business models are best suited.

Read More →
Agricultural Insurance Deep Dive: Strengthening linkages between agri-finance and agri-insurance

Developed with UNDP’s Insurance and Risk Finance Facility, the Agricultural Insurance Deep Dive examines how better integration between agri-insurance and agri-finance can reduce risk, unlock investment, and strengthen resilience across agricultural value chains.

Read More →
Opportunities for Scaling Up Value Chain Finance

Explore what it takes to scale Value Chain Finance (VCF) across diverse markets. This article introduces a three-level framework for intervention — from capital to coordination and policy — and highlights how local and regional offtakers can be empowered to deliver embedded finance at scale.

Read More →

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Related Research

How Capital Enhances Resilience: Five Lessons Learned

Capital is key to resilience. IDH Farmfit Fund, Acumen, and ISF Advisors share five lessons on scaling climate adaptation finance for smallholder farmers — and building stronger, more resilient food systems.

Read More →
The Rise of a New Market: B2B Technologies for Smallholder Farmer Markets

A blog examining the nuances behind business-to-business (B2B) agricultural technology emerging throughout the Global South, and sharing ISF’s perspective on the market trajectory over the coming years.

Read More →
Examining the Fragility of the AgTech Ecosystem Behind the Headline Numbers

A summary of ISF’s comparative analysis between the agtech ecosystem and other ecosystems serving low and middle-income populations, including key drivers of innovation ecosystems, the relative maturity of different countries, and best and worst-case scenarios for the future of agtech ecosystems in the Global South.

Read More →

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Related Research

How Capital Enhances Resilience: Five Lessons Learned

Capital is key to resilience. IDH Farmfit Fund, Acumen, and ISF Advisors share five lessons on scaling climate adaptation finance for smallholder farmers — and building stronger, more resilient food systems.

Read More →
The case of missing middles: Gaps in the development finance landscape, and UNCDF’s positioning in it

Global development finance is failing the world’s most vulnerable economies, leaving critical “white spaces” in high-risk, low-income markets. ISF Advisors’ paper for UNCDF shows how it fills this gap with patient, risk-tolerant, locally embedded capital to unlock investment and transform markets.

Read More →
Blended Finance Playbook for Climate-Smart Agrifood Systems

A practical playbook designed for concessional capital providers, outlining five high-impact blended finance strategies to drive systemic transformation toward climate-resilient agrifood systems.

Read More →

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Women play a central role in rural economies, primarily through the agricultural sector. Yet these women face many barriers, including time poverty, lack of land ownership, fewer agricultural inputs, restrictive social norms, and less access to finance. The emergence of digital agricultural platforms has the potential to help rural women overcome these barriers and improve their livelihoods.

Digital agriculture platforms are a specific subset of AgTechs, defined as models that facilitate direct interactions between multiple users for the purpose of exchange. These platforms are built upon network effects—enabling multiple users on both sides of an exchange to interact, creating shared value for both platform providers and end users. The unique benefits created by digital platforms could be particularly helpful in leveling the playing field for women; however, platforms currently struggle to reach and engage this important customer segment.

In new research from CGAP, ISF Advisors and Value for Women, we look at how digital agricultural platforms can best integrate gender-forward practices, what the major opportunity areas are for creating shared value, and how donors and investors can support these efforts. This research builds on CGAP’s extensive work surrounding women in rural and agricultural livelihoods (WIRAL). In this blog post we summarize a few key findings, with a deeper dive into the opportunities surrounding sex-disaggregated data.

Understanding how digital platforms currently think about gender

Digital platforms have the ability to disintermediate markets, connect multiple users, facilitate information sharing, and provide farmers with a digital financial footprint. These benefits could be especially useful for rural women in overcoming gender-related barriers. For example, the exchange of knowledge and information that are crucial to competitively participate in markets (e.g., prices) is often out of reach for women due to restricted mobility and social norms that keep them out of male-dominated spaces. Digital platforms could connect them to this vital information with far less friction.

Unfortunately, although the digital platform market has grown rapidly, these AgTechs are struggling to reach rural women. While women make up half of smallholder farmers in sub-Saharan Africa, they represent only 25% of AgTech users. Even when AgTechs do reach rural women, usage rates suggest that they are not sufficiently serving them.

Many platforms recognize this missed opportunity and are thinking more about gender—but are only beginning to translate that into concrete action. While there are some encouraging examples of gender-forward efforts, this area is largely not seen as critical to commercial success. Platforms are generally focused on the short-term challenges of achieving profitability and scale. But platforms that integrate long-term gender intentionality into their models could tap into a large opportunity if they implement the best practices proposed in this research.

What are the best practices and biggest opportunities?

In our research, as seen in the figure below, we lay out a curated list of best practices that platforms, and their investors and donors, can adopt—with the ultimate goal of creating shared value for platforms and the women that engage with them.

The two practice areas at the top of this figure serve as foundational best practices that influence a platform’s actions in the other four areas. Internal prioritization of gender in the organizational strategy, budget, policies, etc. is necessary to then enable external-facing best practices around marketing, customer targeting, product design, and providing income generating opportunities.

Building on this, we outline the four biggest opportunities for platforms to increase shared value for themselves and for rural women. As in the best practices, two of these opportunities revolve around establishing a strong internal foundation for platforms to drive commercial and gender outcomes—and ultimately become more gender-forward:

  • Embedding gender into organizational strategy
  • Sex-disaggregated data for better decision making

The other two opportunities center on increasing impact for women as customers and income earners:

  • Experimenting around women-focused innovations
  • Increasing income-generating opportunities for women 

In this blog post, we will take a deeper dive into the opportunities around sex-disaggregated data.

Optimizing sex-disaggregated data for decision making

The collection and analysis of sex-disaggregated data is the typical starting point for increasing gender inclusion both within a company and in the external-facing products and services. A comprehensive business strategy that incorporates gender requires the ability to understand how many women a platform is serving, how well it is currently serving them, and the value women are generating.

Nearly all platforms interviewed collect basic sex-disaggregated data on their end users and their workforce, and nearly half of the providers that have agents on their platforms can also sex-disaggregate that data. However, the majority of platforms do not have a structured process for analyzing this data or taking action on those insights. Only one interviewed platform (CoAmana) seems to be collecting and leveraging sex-disaggregated data that enables it to better engage women customers. For others, there is a significant missed opportunity.

Many providers are aware of this opportunity, but 43% in our sample indicated that it is one of their top three challenges. With a more systematic approach to data collection, analysis, and decision making, platforms can leverage data for:

  1. Target Setting and Prioritization: In our research, 50% of platforms surveyed indicated that they have made gender a top five priority, but they must link this strategy to concrete initiatives, set targets, and define metrics to track progress.
  2. Understanding Customer Patterns: An important (and simple) next step would be to sex-disaggregate existing data—such as customer ratings or satisfaction scores—to understand satisfaction levels for different sub-segments of women (and other users, such as men or youth).
  3. Designing Products: Insight on user patterns can then be leveraged in the product design process. This could result in finding ‘quick wins’ (i.e. shifting land requirements from individual names to family names given barriers for women to access land), or more robust product shifts (i.e. designing products specifically for women or youth).

The role of donors and investors

Importantly, platforms that implement this systematic data-driven approach can then quantify and showcase their impact to potential donors and investors. In fact, there are many entry points for donors and investors to influence platforms to become more gender-forward, especially at early stages of the business.

These entry points include:

  • Building the case for gender inclusion through data and analysis; 
  • Funding or facilitating technical assistance for platforms that want to become more gender-forward; 
  • Providing investment or grant capital to reduce upfront costs and fuel the growth of gender-forward platforms; and 
  • Incentivizing the collection of sex-disaggregated data and broader gender-forward actions. 

Investor and donor support (and influence) will be crucial for platforms to overcome market barriers and failures that currently prevent them from investing fully in rural women.

Related Research

How Capital Enhances Resilience: Five Lessons Learned

Capital is key to resilience. IDH Farmfit Fund, Acumen, and ISF Advisors share five lessons on scaling climate adaptation finance for smallholder farmers — and building stronger, more resilient food systems.

Read More →
The Rise of a New Market: B2B Technologies for Smallholder Farmer Markets

A blog examining the nuances behind business-to-business (B2B) agricultural technology emerging throughout the Global South, and sharing ISF’s perspective on the market trajectory over the coming years.

Read More →
Examining the Fragility of the AgTech Ecosystem Behind the Headline Numbers

A summary of ISF’s comparative analysis between the agtech ecosystem and other ecosystems serving low and middle-income populations, including key drivers of innovation ecosystems, the relative maturity of different countries, and best and worst-case scenarios for the future of agtech ecosystems in the Global South.

Read More →

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

In our 2021 Agricultural Platforms in a Digital Era report, ISF presented a definition of “platforms” defined by two distinguishing factors: 1) they are built upon network effects, enabling multiple users on both sides of an exchange to interact, and 2) unlike traditional “pipeline businesses” they do not produce goods or services, but rather link users together to access goods and services. Since the publication of that report, there has been broad endorsement of our definition of “platforms” and of the need to coalesce around more specific descriptions of AgTech models. 

In this update, we look at marketplace platform models, which connect users with products or integrated products and services. This growing subset of Digital Platforms are well positioned to help smallholder farmers and agricultural small- and medium-sized enterprises (agri-SMEs) overcome many of the market barriers inherent in the sector.

Types of marketplace models

Our 2021 report revealed a wide range of marketplace platform models operating in the agricultural sector. Broadly, we can divide them into three models:

  1. Product marketplace: connects smallholder farmers to physical markets both to and from the farm, including farm inputs suppliers and various kinds of off-takers (processors, trader, retailers, consumers)
  2. Integrated product and services marketplace: facilitates access to a holistic, bundled offer to farmers. Similar to a product marketplace, but offering broader range of services to farmers
  3. Services marketplace: shared economy platform that links farmers to equipment and/or other service providers.

We outlined eight sub-categories under these models, which continue to be the prevailing types in the market as shown in this graphic:

However, recent landscaping of the sub-Saharan Africa market revealed some updates to how these sub-categories of platform models are emerging.  

  • Many/most digital platforms are not truly open marketplaces with a large range of product and service providers engaged. Rather, many involve small numbers of curated partners with single offerings in each category (e.g. Digifarm)  
  • Many digital platforms are having to invest heavily in enabling infrastructure (e.g. transport, logistics, warehousing, field forces) to make they models work for smallholder-anchored markets (e.g. AFEX’s sourcing network, Twiga’s upstream investment in primary production) 
  • Many digital platforms are also running more traditional pipeline business offerings alongside their digital platforms (e.g. Coamana; AFEX)  
  • Many digital platforms are starting as agriculturally-focused and then moving to multi-product category marketplaces to include a range of consumer goods (e.g. DeHatt; Pinduoduo)

Platform design & scaling

Compared to pipeline business models, the unique characteristics of platforms should make achieving scale easier, at least after the initial start-up costs. But platforms will still struggle to reach profitability given the difficulty of generating additional value for users—and the highly localized nature of the agriculture sector makes scaling profitability even more complex. In our 2021 report, we outlined five key design decisions that platform providers must consider:

  1. Who: target customer and problem solved
  2. Where: value chain and geographies
  3. What: service offering
  4. How to Engage: customer engagement model
  5. How to Monetize: revenue model

Recent analysis shows that most platforms are still struggling to make their economics work. This is leading many to run more direct B2B pipeline business offerings alongside their platform, while some are also still reliant on donor funding. Many platforms recognize that integrated credit is key (giving rise to the term AgFinTech), but they are struggling to raise and structure the right capital to support these offerings. In the sub-Saharan Africa market, successful platforms remain heavily reliant on agent networks to scale, even after achieving a product-market fit.

Finance offerings within platforms

Most marketplaces integrate payments as a form of financial services, and some—as mentioned above—are expanding their model to include provision of financial services. In our recent landscaping, we identified four specific forms of financing being offered within marketplace models:

  • Vendor financing provides financing for products and services sold on the platform
  • Input financing provides credit to smallholder farmers in the form of in-kind inputs (or cash for labor) at the beginning of the season, generally to be repaid at harvest
  • Asset financing focuses on productive assets often financed through innovative business models such as PAYGO
  • Insurance offers bundled insurance for products or services offered on the platform

The graphic below illustrates examples of in-platform financing within the sub-Saharan Africa agricultural market.

Geographic differences

The maturity of platform models varies greatly by region. The majority of large ag-focused platforms are headquartered in India and China and are operated by tech companies. Many of these models have already reached significant scale, including DeHatt, Gramophone, Pinduoduo, Tanihub, and Rural Taobao. These models have grown rapidly on the back of densely populated markets, with strong enabling market infrastructure and consumers who are used to e-commerce in other sectors. Of particular note is Pinduoduo, which launched in 2017 as an ag-focused marketplace and now has over 880 million active users.  

At this time, most marketplaces in Africa remain small in size. Kenya is a hub for marketplaces, including Digifarm and Copia who both have over 1M users, fueled by the prevalence of mobile money and the relatively flexible nature of regulators. Other players, such as Hello Tractor and WeFarm (social connectivity platform), are currently capitalizing on their achievements as true platform models to now offer diversified offerings. Altogether, Kenya and Nigeria are the top markets in the region, receiving 96% of AgTech venture funding.

In Latin America, AgTechs are primarily concentrated in Brazil (51%) and Argentina (23%), as shown in this IBD mapping from 2019. Marketplace growth in the region has largely been fueled by mature farming systems, relatively tight value chains, urban wealth, and relatively better logistics. A select few product marketplaces, such as Smattcom and Frubana, have expanded into multiple markets.

Overall, these regional differences reveal some interesting dynamics. In particular, the relative scale of platform models in China and India are due to three key enablers that hold lessons for other markets looking to scale: 1) density and formalization; 2) maturity of enabling systems; and 3) progressive regulatory environment.

Persistent challenges

Despite their growth, platforms still face large barriers in the agricultural market. The localized nature of the sector limits network effects and increases customer acquisition costs. To successfully scale, platforms need the correct monetization strategy. 

One of the most prevalent challenges of marketplaces is the physical capital associated with the exchange of value between users. Successful e-commerce platforms, such as Amazon, have employed backwards integration to bring their shipping and packaging logistics in-house. In the agricultural sector, this challenge is amplified by the weak infrastructure in rural communities and developing economies writ large. Platforms may have no choice but to build the infrastructure themselves—as was the case with AFEX in Nigeria, which built a network of physical storage and logistics throughout the country, including 113 warehouses.

The path forward

One way we can continue to improve outcomes for ag-focused digital platforms in emerging markets is to leverage lessons from more mature sectors and markets. For example, in the US, venture capital is largely flowing into companies that have a downstream link to consumers (e.g., GrubHub, DoorDash). The same holds true for the agricultural sector, in which some of the most successful models are product marketplaces with a direct consumer link, whether it be an end consumer or a restaurant/aggregator. Plant AG, for instance, is developing a “farm to plate” platform and plans to grow their own food to sell to consumers. They raised $800M in their early stage VC round in 2021.

In Europe, similarly, the biggest deals of 2021 centered around direct-to-consumer platform models, such as Gorilla ($1B), Fink Food ($750M), and Wolt ($530M). Investments in the overall food tech space tripled to $10B in 2021, while AgTech investments grew only slightly to $900M. Investments in Europe tend to be on a smaller scale than in the US, but with significant opportunity for growth.

These adjacent markets reveal some cross-cutting learnings for platforms in smallholder agricultural markets, including:

  1. The emergence of integrated credit is a widespread platform trend. Companies in the United States (FBN) and other sectors (SafeBoda) have introduced financing opportunities for both customers and workers, similar to what we observed in the shift to “AgFinTechs.”
  2. There is a strong focus on the end consumer. This can be seen in the successful capital raises of start-ups with direct consumer links. Furthermore, the introduction of financial services specifically for platform workers demonstrates that platform providers are treating their own workers as customers as well.

Overall, platforms continue to offer a major pathway to overcoming the scaling challenge in smallholder agricultural markets. More research and further clarification of definitions and models will help digital platforms unleash their full potential.

Related Research

AgTech Investment in Emerging Markets 2025

AgTech investment across emerging markets is no longer one story. Drawing on $4.39 billion in funding across 17 markets, this State of the Sector report examines what’s driving increasingly divergent investment trajectories and introduces the Investable Frontier, a framework for understanding where different types of capital and business models are best suited.

Read More →
Agricultural Insurance Deep Dive: Strengthening linkages between agri-finance and agri-insurance

Developed with UNDP’s Insurance and Risk Finance Facility, the Agricultural Insurance Deep Dive examines how better integration between agri-insurance and agri-finance can reduce risk, unlock investment, and strengthen resilience across agricultural value chains.

Read More →
Opportunities for Scaling Up Value Chain Finance

Explore what it takes to scale Value Chain Finance (VCF) across diverse markets. This article introduces a three-level framework for intervention — from capital to coordination and policy — and highlights how local and regional offtakers can be empowered to deliver embedded finance at scale.

Read More →

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Data is growing in importance across all sectors, including agriculture. With the advent of new digital technologies and innovative business models, the amount of available data and potential use cases are increasing. Agricultural and Fintech innovators that recognize this trend are utilizing data in new ways, from creating digital platforms to delivering new, data-enabled services. Many are also exploring data partnerships, combining the power of multiple datasets to create greater impact for smallholder farmers.

In a new case study, ISF Advisors examined 33 engagements between Mercy Corps’ AgriFin program and 14 partners across four different countries. We found that around a quarter of the portfolio of AgriFin engagements—spanning various use cases—featured a strong data-sharing component. Underpinning many of these engagements are complex negotiations about how data sharing can unlock service delivery and enable different social and commercial outcomes for different players.

By analyzing these 33 engagements, we have uncovered lessons about the common barriers faced by data-sharing arrangements. In distilling these lessons, we hope to provide practical guidance and tools for overcoming these barriers to the broader ecosystem of actors involved in optimizing data sharing for agriculture.

The promise and role of data sharing in agriculture

Smallholder farmers’ remote location and lack of linkages to global markets have traditionally hindered robust data collection. But the penetration of mobile phones and other digital technologies into rural areas has made data collection and sharing significantly easier in recent years. New technologies such as drones, satellites, and sensors have also expanded data collection options.

Simultaneously, private companies are increasingly seeing farmers as potential customers and are turning to data to expand their understanding of this market segment. By entering into data-sharing partnerships, these companies can leverage combined datasets to develop new, tailored products for smallholder farmers, integrate farmer risk scoring, and optimize customer interactions. Some companies are even utilizing combined datasets to create entirely new business models where data itself is the commodity, sold directly to customers or to businesses that want to know more about their customers.

Despite the increasing use of data in agriculture, it is still in a nascent stage of development. At a foundational level, practitioners don’t even have a common data taxonomy to talk about what agriculture data is—making it difficult to learn from what others are doing. Additionally, many investments into new data-enabled platforms, models, services, and systems are still working out how to operate profitably at scale. Data-sharing engagements, while promising, tend to lack sophistication on several levels: 1) the types of data being shared (limited primarily to demographic data); 2) the format of data sharing (primarily static reports); 3) the level of analysis applied to the data (primarily simple analysis at the farmer level; and 4) the types of data-sharing agreements (primarily bilateral).

Barriers to effective data sharing

As might be expected in such complex arrangements involving a variety of actors, analysis of early data-sharing partnerships shows a range of barriers. Factors like the type of partners, type of data, use case for the data, and country where data is shared typically shape which barriers a partnership will face.

Looking at the AgriFin portfolio, we can see that the primary barriers to establishing a data-sharing agreement can be classified as:

  • Cultural (e.g., the company’s leadership or established internal data-sharing practices);
  • Capacity (e.g., the skills, technology, and experience each partner brings to the table);
  • Commercial (e.g., example, the cost of data and how partners treat intellectual property and/or competition in the data space);
  • Reputational (e.g., how partners think about the riskiness of sharing personal data); and
  • Regulatory (e.g., national data policies and legal jusdictions).

Even for organizations that recognize the potential of data in agriculture, these barriers can prevent them from effectively assessing the business case for investment within different regulatory environments. Once a data-sharing agreement is created, the barriers tend to shift. For example, many organizations don’t have a dedicated team working on the engagement, which can lead to delays in sharing data. Data-sharing agreements also suffer when the partners don’t have on-the-ground staff members who understand how to work with disaggregated farmers.

Certain barriers are more apparent with certain types of partners. For instance, government and nonprofit actors often face skill and capacity barriers, while financial service providers often contend more with cultural and regulatory barriers. While each use case is unique, we have distilled a common taxonomy of reference barriers and a mapping of where they’re most likely to show up in different partnerships (see full case study for more detail).

Empowering effective data sharing

Research and learning about how to effectively use data in different agricultural use cases and partnership models is quickly accelerating. For example, donor-funded programs like AgriFin are working with providers to test new service delivery models, using data as a key enabler. In the broader ecosystem, a number of open data initiatives—such as GODAN and GEOGLAM—are establishing much-needed standards, open datasets, and enabling resources for different actors.

Our case study takes stock of what has been learned so far about effective data sharing within AgriFin’s portfolio. In addition to the lessons on barriers noted above, the case study contains the following tools:

  • Reference taxonomies that distill how the AgriFin program considers key dimensions of data within data-sharing partnerships;
  • A data readiness tool that provides a holistic way of assessing organizational readiness to start working with data internally or in data-sharing partnerships; and
  • A data-sharing agreement process that distills the common steps, barriers, and learnings from the AgriFin program.

Our hope is that these tools can be used broadly by the agricultural community in understanding why data is important and how you can use it to improve the lives of smallholder farmers.

For more information, download the case study.

Related Research

How Capital Enhances Resilience: Five Lessons Learned

Capital is key to resilience. IDH Farmfit Fund, Acumen, and ISF Advisors share five lessons on scaling climate adaptation finance for smallholder farmers — and building stronger, more resilient food systems.

Read More →
The Rise of a New Market: B2B Technologies for Smallholder Farmer Markets

A blog examining the nuances behind business-to-business (B2B) agricultural technology emerging throughout the Global South, and sharing ISF’s perspective on the market trajectory over the coming years.

Read More →
Examining the Fragility of the AgTech Ecosystem Behind the Headline Numbers

A summary of ISF’s comparative analysis between the agtech ecosystem and other ecosystems serving low and middle-income populations, including key drivers of innovation ecosystems, the relative maturity of different countries, and best and worst-case scenarios for the future of agtech ecosystems in the Global South.

Read More →

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.